MLS Commissioner Pushes for Christian Pulisic to Join New York City FC

FolioPitch.com – 28 July 2026 | The MLS Commissioner admits hope for New York City’s Pulisic pursuit: ‘Become a star’ – a statement that has reignited speculation about Christian Pulisic‘s future. Don Garber, the Major League Soccer commissioner, openly expressed his desire to see the American international return to the United States and play for New York City FC. In an interview on Fox News’ ‘One Nation With Brian Kilmeade,’ Garber said, ‘I hope they can sign Christian Pulisic. I think he’d be fantastic in our league, and I think our league would be fantastic for him. Give him the opportunity to do what Landon Donovan did: come to Major League Soccer, take flight, become a star, and be right next to his family in Pennsylvania.’

Garber’s comments come after a summer of rumors linking Pulisic with a move to New York City. The 25-year-old winger, currently under contract with AC Milan until 2027, was reportedly interested in the salary and project offered by the MLS club. However, Milan swiftly shut down any immediate transfer, informing New York City that their star was not for sale. Despite this, with a new contract yet to be signed, the door remains ajar for future negotiations. Milan’s owner, Gerry Cardinale, has made it clear he wants to keep Pulisic at the forefront of the club’s project, but the player’s long-term commitment remains uncertain.

The MLS Commissioner admits hope for New York City’s Pulisic pursuit: ‘Become a star’ – and his words underscore a broader strategy to attract top American talent to the league. Pulisic, who rose to prominence at Borussia Dortmund before a high-profile move to Chelsea, has always been seen as a potential marquee signing for MLS. His roots in Hershey, Pennsylvania, make a return home particularly appealing, both for the player and the league. Garber emphasized that New York City FC would be at the top of the list if Pulisic decides to join MLS, saying, ‘We believe Christian will want to play in the MLS, that he wants to return home. Whenever that happens, we believe and hope that New York City FC is at the top of the list of teams he would like to play for.’

But what would a move mean for Pulisic’s career? At 25, he is still in his prime. After a successful stint at Milan, where he has contributed with goals and assists, leaving Europe might seem premature. However, the lure of being a franchise player in a growing league, combined with family proximity, could prove irresistible. Pulisic’s marketability would also skyrocket, as he would become the face of MLS alongside other stars like Lionel Messi. Yet, Milan’s resistance is formidable. The Rossoneri invested heavily in Pulisic and see him as a key part of their attacking lineup. A transfer would likely require a significant fee, possibly exceeding $20 million, which could be a stumbling block for MLS.

Garber’s comments are not just wishful thinking; they reflect a strategic push to keep American stars at home. Landon Donovan’s legacy in MLS serves as a blueprint: after a successful European career, Donovan returned to the LA Galaxy and became a legend. Pulisic could follow a similar path, but the timing is crucial. With the 2026 World Cup on the horizon, playing in MLS might keep him in the spotlight for the national team. However, Pulisic’s current form at Milan suggests he is still capable of competing at the highest level. A move now could be seen as a step back, but Garber believes the opposite.

The MLS Commissioner admits hope for New York City’s Pulisic pursuit: ‘Become a star’ – a phrase that captures the league’s ambition. However, it’s not just about one player. Pulisic’s arrival would elevate the profile of MLS globally, attract more young American talent to stay home, and boost TV ratings. Yet, the decision ultimately rests with Pulisic and AC Milan. For now, Garber’s words are a rallying cry for American soccer fans who dream of seeing their national team star shine on home soil. As the transfer window approaches, the saga is far from over.

In conclusion, the MLS Commissioner’s public admission signals a clear intention to bring Christian Pulisic to New York City FC. While AC Milan has temporarily blocked the move, the long-term possibility remains alive. Pulisic’s potential return to the United States would be a landmark moment for MLS, blending sentimental value with commercial gain. For now, fans can only watch and wait as the drama unfolds.